Lucy's Dud Of A Key (Fairy Tail) (Patreon)

Rumor has it an old man has Aquarius’ new key that Lucy’s looking for and she’ll do whatever it takes to get her friend back. Unfortunately, that means bargaining with an old pervert.

After Aquarius’ key broke during the Tartaros invasion, Lucy thought it was over between her and Aquarius. Her dearest and oldest friend now gone from her life forever and she couldn’t do anything about it. But when the mermaid came back to save her against Brandish, and left behind the hint that she had a new key somewhere out in the world, she knew that she had to find her friend again. Of course, Lucy wasn’t the type to just abandon her friends and look for Aquarius like that. But whenever she had the chance, she would look for hints or clues about Golden Keys and even ask other spirits if they knew anything that could help her out.

Fortunately, after all of her searching, there was one solid lead about where a golden key could be. Lucy had no idea what spirit would be held within the key or if it was even real or not, but rumor around it was that an old man was in possession of the key and willing to get rid of it if someone truly wanted it. And that was all the reason Lucy needed to get on the hunt. Thankfully, it didn’t take her long to find the old man. Nor did it take her long to ask for the key, practically begging him the moment he turned his attention to her. “Please, Sir. I’m a Celestial Wizard. Having a golden key, especially one that might belong to someone important to me would help me a lot.”

“Well, you do seem like a sweet girl. Kind, too. But I can’t give my key away to anyone. And I certainly can’t give it away for free. Which, it looks like you can’t pay since you have almost nothing with you.” Lucy’s heart sank in her chest as the old man paused to consider things, a smile coming to his face a moment later and causing her to get a bit hopeful. “I’ll tell you what. It’s been ages since I’ve… We’ll say ‘had a bit of fun’. If you help me with that and let me get a taste of that pretty mouth, I’ll give you the key. No charge.”

Lucy couldn’t believe what she heard from this old man. Sure, he looked like the kind of geezer that would try and pull a fast one on her, but he held the key in her hand and it was close enough that she could almost hear Aquarius screaming at her once again. She let out a heavy sigh and looked around the two of them to be sure that no one could see them. Without saying a word, she grabbed his wrist and pulled him into a nearby alley, so focused on getting hidden that she missed his finger inscribing something on the wall as they moved.

When she was finally satisfied with where they were, Lucy wrapped her arms around the old man’s neck and pulled him close enough for their lips to brush together for a moment. “Don’t tell a soul about this, you old pervert… I’m only doing this because I want to get my friend back and I don’t have anything to bargain with.” Her voice was low and almost sounded afraid of what was to happen if she kept this up. But instead of arguing to do something else with him, Lucy didn’t give him a chance to say a word before she caught him in a quick and lustful kiss. A quick kiss that easily led to a second and a third with him.

When he didn’t bother pushing her away, Lucy thought that she had this in the bag. That she could easily get Aquarius’ key and wash her mouth out later and forget about the whole thing. But as their kisses began to linger from one to another, the length between them quickening and the old man’s grip on her body getting tighter, something clicked in her mind. And Lucy didn’t hesitate to pull herself away from his lips and look the old man in the eye. “H-Hey… Don’t think that you can get away with--”

“What? Was I not clear? I wanted a blowjob from you. I just thought you were getting yourself in the mood for it.”

Lucy’s cheeks flared a deep shade of red as she pulled away from him, embarrassment filling her at the fact that she didn’t understand just what he meant. With all the lewd and unsightly things that happened both to her and around her since she joined Fairy Tail and she didn’t realize that’s what he meant? Her heart sank in her chest as she looked him in the eyes and slowly, carefully starting to sink to her knees. “If I’m going to do this, I definitely don’t want you telling anyone about it, okay?” She did her best to shoot an angry glare at the man as her cheeks stayed a bright shade of red.

“Sure, sure. I won’t tell a soul about this.”

With their verbal agreement to keep this secret out of the way, Lucy felt her heart starting to race as she undid his pants, pulling everything down to his ankles to expose his cock to her. Much to her surprise, the thing was massive for a man of his age, almost spanning the length of her forearm. But she couldn’t bring herself to complain or back out at this point. She was just too deep into things. So, without saying a word to the old man, Lucy quickly wrapped her lips around the head of his shaft before wrapping her hand around the base of it.

Fortunately, it wasn’t as thick as it was long or she was going to be in trouble. But as she began bobbing her head up and down the length of his member, stroking what wasn’t in her mouth, Lucy was fortunate enough to hear the old man starting to groan above her. She did her best to ignore the fact that he was groaning in pleasure because of her mouth and tried to do her best to make him cum. It wasn’t the first blowjob that she had given, but she didn’t like the fact that she was sucking off an old man and wanted this done as quickly as possible.

Lucy coiled her tongue around the length of his shaft as she pushed herself down the first half of it, stopping the moment she felt it threaten to push into the back of her throat. Her eyes fluttered shut and tears started to fill them as his hands swiftly came to the back of her head, keeping her from being able to pull herself back and off from around his member. Luckily, being forced to stay in place as she sucked him off allowed her throat to adjust to him being inside of her. And in less than a moment, her throat sputtering around his member stopped and allowed her to start moving along his length again.

Whenever she pushed herself down, she kept her tongue coiled around the old man’s cock. And when she pulled herself back up as far as he would let her, Lucy kept her tongue placed firmly against the underside of his shaft. She may not have enjoyed the taste of his dick on her tongue, but the way he groaned above her made it clear that he was enjoying the feeling of her tongue dancing around his member. And when his grip on the back of her head grew tighter and tighter, his cock starting to throb in her mouth, she had a feeling that he was getting close to cumming for her.

Unfortunately, it was about at that point that the old man used his grip on the back of Lucy’s head to pull her completely off of his cock and instead let her rest underneath it for a moment. He didn’t shy away from pushing it down against her cheek and making her take in the heavy scent of it while she was there, a quiet chuckle in his throat. “W-What’s so funny? You said you wanted a--” Lucy was quickly cut off by the feeling of his dick slapping down against her lips once again.

“Oh, I know what I said. But I think I was wrong. Now that I know how your mouth feels, I don’t think it will be enough to make me cum. Sure, you know what you’re doing, but it’s not going to give me what I want. I could be wrong, though. But…” Without finishing his sentence, the old man used his grip on Lucy’s head to force her to the base of his member and keep her there as he spoke. “There’s only one way to find out. If I’m not satisfied, I might need to use another part of your body. Maybe those plump tits of yours.~”

Being forced to the base of this old man’s cock was something that Lucy didn’t expect to happen. She also didn’t expect to be able to bring one of her hands to her neck and feel his shaft throbbing and pulsing through her skin. Another thing Lucy didn’t expect was to feel the old man erupt in her throat after just saying that her mouth wouldn’t be enough for him. Her heart skipped a few beats in her chest as he unloaded inside of her, keeping her in place and forcing her to swallow down each and every drop.

Unfortunately, even as he came down her throat, some of his seed pouring directly into her stomach, Lucy wasn’t able to move her head away from his base. She almost immediately felt the lack of oxygen as he held her there, leaving Lucy to choke and sputter around his shaft with each swallow of his seed. Right up until the point he pulled her back and slapped his cock down onto her cheek again, some of his seed splattering against her skin and into her hair. However, just as she went to open her mouth to scold him. Lucy was quickly cut off by him placing his dick against her soft lips.

“Yeah… I’m sorry to say, but that wasn’t really enough to satisfy me. I think I’m going to need to use your pussy in order to properly get off. But I promise, as soon as I cum from your pussy, I’ll give you the key and forget this ever happened.”

Lucy could see a devious smirk on his lips as he looked down at her, making her doubt that he would actually forget it happened or give her the key right away. But in this position, she didn’t have a choice but to believe him. Especially when he used his surprisingly strong grip on her body to push her down onto her hands and knees so he could get behind her. A nervous and almost fearful gasp left Lucy’s lips when she looked ahead of her and noticed the street in front of her. She couldn’t see anyone walking back and forth close enough to be able to see or hear them, but it caused her heart to sink into her stomach all the same.

But the feeling of his hands adjusting her shorts in order to get them out of the way prompted Lucy to bring one of her hands to her lips to try and keep herself quiet. She knew what was about to come and she didn’t think she could keep herself quiet if a cock that big forced its way into her. Unfortunately, Lucy was far more right than she expected she would be. Not only was she unable to keep herself quiet as the old man forced his way deep into her cunt, but the fact that she held onto her mouth to try and keep herself quiet also caused her to slump onto the ground and press her cheek into the dirt as he started to thrust into her.

Hot and heavy breaths almost immediately spilled from her lips as he hammered away deep into her cunt, forcing her to feel the tip of his shaft pounding against the entrance to her womb with each and every thrust. Lucy quickly pulled her hand away from her mouth to try and prop herself off of the ground, hoping to get her face and her hair out of the dirt while this old man fucked her from behind. Unfortunately, as soon as she did so, he grabbed a firm hold of her wrist and yanked her hand behind her back.

From here, Lucy could feel that he was in complete control of what was going to happen. The way he gripped onto her arm, the way he slammed deep into her with every thrust, and the way he somehow used his weight to keep her face pressed firmly into the ground. In the back of her mind, she wondered if he was an old man after all, or if he was another wizard that was just trying to stay out of sight and avoid anyone finding him. Whatever the reason for his strength, Lucy found her body slowly growing more and more adjusted to the pleasure of being filled and accepting every ounce of bliss that coursed through her.

Of course, she didn’t want to cum from this old, disgusting pervert of a man fucking her. But as he brought his free hand to her plump rear end and began caressing it while fucking her, Lucy couldn’t stop herself from letting out a few loud and shameful moans. A few moans that seemed to be heard by someone as soon as they were walking past the alley that she was being fucked in. Because in less than a moment after she moaned out for the old man, she noticed someone around her age turn their head to look into the alley.

Her cheeks immediately flared up a deep shade of red as the old man picked up the pace despite them both being seen by whoever this was. She wanted to turn her head and hide away from this happening, but as the young man started taking pictures of them, Lucy felt her heart sinking even more into her gut. Being fucked by an old pervert was bad enough, but at least he promised to not tell anyone about things. But getting caught by someone who just wanted to snap a few pictures? She couldn’t believe just how unlucky she was getting.

Fortunately, the young man started to walk away from them as soon as her inner walls started to quiver and convulse around the shaft inside of her. In the back of her mind, Lucy was relieved that no one would be taking pictures of her cumming around an old man’s cock. Especially with the way this old man throbbed and pulsed inside of her, clearly ready to cum and erupt into her womb without anything stopping him.

Not even a moment after the young man walked away from the two of them, Lucy felt a flood of heat suddenly fill her womb while the old man throbbed inside of her. She immediately knew what it was and gasped in a combination of denial and pleasure as she came right along with the old man, the feeling of him erupting inside of her pushing her over the edge of her own unwanted orgasm. Her breath hitched in her throat as he continued to thrust deep into her while he came inside of her, rope after rope of his thick and potent seed flooding into her womb and painting her insides a thick shade of white.

All the while, the world around Lucy started to spin as lust, pleasure, and confusion filled her mind. Did this old man really just cum inside of her while they were in public? Did she cum from him filling her with his seed? Why was he still thrusting inside of her? Was that man her age able to hear them cum like this? All of these thoughts rushed through her mind as the old man’s grip on her body started to loosen. Though, it only loosened for a moment before he suddenly grabbed onto her again and lipped her over so that she was on her back.

Before she could properly process just what was going on now that she was on her back, Lucy felt the old man’s lips crash against her own. She felt one of his hands latch onto her breast as the other one remained firmly on her hips, keeping her in place while he pulled out of her and pressed his tip directly against her ass. Lucy’s eyes went wide in fear when she realized just what this old man was going to do to her.

Unfortunately, with him stealing kiss after kiss from her lips as he held her onto her back, the only thing Lucy could do was scream against his lips as his cock swiftly plunged deep into her asshole. Hot and heavy breaths spilled from her and muffled against his lips when he immediately started to thrust into her ass, filling out and stretching her anal walls while she instinctively wrapped her legs around his waist. In the back of her mind, Lucy knew that she didn't want him to fuck her ass. She knew that having him fuck her like this was only pushing the terms of their deal as far as he possibly could.

However, Lucy couldn’t bring herself to pull away from him as his thrusts got faster and rougher by the moment. As if he was trying to leave some kind of imprint on her body for when he was done with her. And she knew she couldn’t do anything about it as he pulled away from her and instead looked deep into her eyes, forcing her to see the look of lust and desire that swirled within his gaze. “H-How dare you… You said…”

“I know what I said, girl. You want the key and your mouth wasn’t enough to leave me satisfied. I hoped your pussy would be, but when I came and still wanted to keep fucking you, I knew I had to take your ass as well.”

Lucy’s heart skipped a few beats in her chest when she heard his explanation. It didn’t make sense to her in the slightest. Though, she knew that part of the reason it didn’t make sense was the fact that having her asshole fucked like this was causing a massive amount of pleasure and bliss to cloud her mind and her thoughts. Her eyes started to roll into the back of her head when he pulled the hand that was on her hip to her breasts, kneading and playing with her large mounds while he fucked her.

The feeling of his fingers playing with and sinking into her breasts only enhanced the pleasure that Lucy was feeling. It only made the rushes of bliss that filled her from each and every thrust become that much more intense, that much more desirable. And before she knew it, Lucy found herself moaning up a storm as he plunged into her over and over again, her head tilted back and her eyes fluttering shut.

Somehow, this old man was able to bring Lucy the kind of pleasure that she hadn’t felt in ages. The kind of pleasure that made her forget about the world and focus solely on him as he thrust into her time and time again. All while she still, somehow, managed to force herself to be unhappy about the situation that she was in. Deep down, she knew that she had to have looked like a slut to anyone that might be able to see her. Not only was she on her back with her legs wrapped around this old man’s waist, but she was moaning up a storm with each thrust that filled her all while she had a look of pleasure written all over her face.

And some part of her couldn’t help but feel happy about that. Maybe it was because of the way this old man fucked her. Maybe it was because of just how big this man’s cock was and how deep it reached into her. Or maybe it was the simple fact that she was a bit of a masochist and enjoyed the way he dominated over her and held her down in order to fuck her. Whatever the reason actually was, Lucy couldn’t stop herself from moaning as she opened her eyes and looked at the old man, silently wondering if he was going to cum inside of her ass just like he came in her pussy.

Lucy was so lost in her pleasure that, before she knew it, she felt the old man cumming inside of her once again. And she came right alongside him, her anal walls clamping down around his shaft as he continued to rock himself back and forth inside of her. Her heart raced in her chest as she felt each and every rope of his cum suddenly flood her asshole. All while her legs remained tightly around his body.

Hot and heavy breaths left Lucy’s lips as the old man started to carefully pull himself back out of her, slapping his cock down against her stomach and stroking out another rope or two onto her. However, with the sheer amount of bliss that clouded her mind, she couldn’t bring herself to say anything. All she could do was bask in the afterglow of her orgasm and remain there in silence, watching as the man adjusted his pants and stood up beside her.

Fortunately, he didn’t leave her there to run around with her key and make her try all over again to get it back from him. So when the pleasure started to slowly die down, Lucy carefully hoisted herself to her feet and looked him in the eyes before holding out one of her hands. “Alright… I’ve done--”

“Yeah, yeah. You’ve done what I asked you to. I’m a man of my word. I’m satisfied and you’ve earned the key that you want.”

Lusy let out a gentle sight as he reached for the golden key that she saw him carrying, the one that she was hoping would have Aquarius linked to it so that she could see her friend again. When he gave it to her, she couldn’t believe that she actually had another golden key in her hand, her heart starting to race in sheer excitement. She couldn’t even bring herself to worry about the fact that, if this key did indeed have Aquarius, the mermaid would end up seeing her partially undressed and dripping with cum.

But the excitement that she felt pushed her to not care about that and hoist the key into the air, pushing her magic into it to try and draw out her friend. However, after what felt like an eternity of the key giving no kind of response to her magic, Lucy paused and looked at the old man, wondering just what was going on. At this point, every key that she had used in the past had reacted in one form or another. But this golden one? Nothing.

“Alright, old man, what’s going on? Did you somehow tamper with the key? Rumor has it this is the only golden key to appear in the last few years since I started my search. How can this key not have Aquarius in it?!” Unfortunately for Lucy, the old man simply shrugged and let out a sigh before taking a step back away from her.

“I’m sorry, girl. The key’s fake. It always has been. I never told anyone about it and never told anyone that it was real either. If whatever intel you had told you it was real, that’s because they were wrong. That’s not my fault.”

Lucy’s heart stopped cold when she heard his explanation. “If you knew it was fake, why make me do all that just to get it from you? What’s the point in that?!”

“I’ve been trying to sell that key for ages now. I don’t even want it anymore. So when a beautiful young girl came along and said she’d do anything she could for it, it makes sense that I would take advantage of that, right?” The old man simply chuckled as he brought his hand to the wall and pressed his fingertips against it, dark yellow magic coming from his fingertips. “Though, I certainly earned the money I would have lost if I gave it to you for free. Recording our fun made me quite the profit. People seem to like you. Though, I still have no idea who you are.”

Lucy’s heart sank into her chest at the admittance of recording the two of them fucking. “B-But you said that you wouldn’t tell anyone about this! J-Just what is wrong with you?!” Tears started to fill Lucy’s eyes as she took a step closer toward the old man, anger and betrayal fueling her to do something to him. Though, she didn’t know what. Especially when he pulled his hand away from the wall and took another step away from her.

“It’s clear you’re made, but I still kept my promise to you. I didn’t tell anyone about that recording. They found it on their own while I was recording it and then did what they wanted. That’s not on me. You should find that young man that took a few pictures and see what he has to say about it.”

Lucy glared at the old man as she pushed the key between her breasts, keeping it in her cleavage so that she couldn’t lose it as she chased after the young man that caught them. But before she made her way out the alley, she turned her attention to the man that fucked her and slapped him as hard as she could. Unfortunately, he stayed firm on his feet as she dashed away, hoping to catch the young man that had taken a few pictures of her getting fucked.

However, completely unaware of the fact that the old man was still recording her, Lucy ran with cum leaking out of her asshole and her cunt. She didn’t know that he kept his view perfectly on her plump rear end to see her ass cheeks jiggle and shake with each step, the cum he pumped into her slowly and steadily dripping out of her and onto the ground. Nor did she know if she could even find that young man from earlier. But that didn’t matter to her as she ran away from the old man, hoping to never see or hear from him again. Though, somewhere in the back of her mind, she knew she might if he tried to say she stole the key from him.